I want to know what would happen if we didn’t define and label things, specifically music because that’s what I’m thinking about right now. It’s not as if this question hasn’t been chewed over a thousand times before by thousands of people but it’s never, as far as I know (and I’ll admit I haven’t done any extensive research on really trustworthy sources like Wikipedia or anything) been answered.
So let’s say, for purposes of discussion, that for *some reason, no one can or even wants to label different kinds of music.
Take a classical musician, (let’s say she plays the piano) but she doesn’t know that she’s “classically” trained nor does her teacher or anyone she knows. She does know that she heard a great recording recently of a group playing a combo of banjo, fiddle, guitar, mandolin, dobro, and of course vocals which might be called, if this were a labeled world, bluegrass. She really liked it and she’s started experimenting with her instrument, incorporating this new style and mixing it with the way she played before. Now she goes to her friend who is a skilled pannist (not pianist, pannist, who also has no idea of playing in any kind of genre) and shows him what she’s been working on. He thinks it’s great and decides to take a break from his experiments with combining steel drums and electronic dance music (labeled = dubstep) and they start playing together, each bringing their own thoughts and styles to the music. In the end the labeled product would be a classical/dubstep/bluegrass/steel band sound. But that wouldn’t matter; it’d just be some sweet, perhaps somewhat bizarre music that would continue to evolve.
I’m not saying that having genres and names for different kinds of music is bad at all. The trouble develops when we decide that one type of music is “best.” That isn’t to say I’m going to stop cringing inwardly every time I hear a really dreadful country western song or that I’ll ever love Attack Attack! (here's a different Attack! Attack! and they're Welsh, would ya look at that...) but I think keeping an open mind in music is as important as keeping an open mind about religion. The kind of mutation that I described above **does happen, and it’s great when it occurs, but I think it would happen much more if ***people didn’t get stuck in their own genres (which can happen entirely without anyone being aware of it) and not think to look at others. I guess in the end it’s people that are the problem here, not language.
Go forth, and listen to something you think you hate! And if you have thoughts on this please contact me (Willa, in this case) I’d love to hear them.
*Maybe a kitten accidentally sneezed a large portion of the music loving population into an alternate dimension? I don’t know.
**Usually after hours and a few drinks, or frequently when people just get bored and experiment. Either way, marvelous things happen.
***I realize writing this that it’s actually more of an issue for people who don’t play anything.